Decisions - BC Financial Services Tribunal

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Arvind Shankar v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2018mba001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 25, 2019

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2018-MBA-001

Decision Number:
2018-MBA-001(a)
Soheil Arman Kia (aka Soheil Armon Kia) v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-MBA-002b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 14, 2018

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2017-MBA-002

Decision Number:
2017-MBA-002(b)
Roger Bruce Schoen v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

COSTS DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-002c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 29, 2018

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2017-RSA-002(c)
Financial Institutions Commission v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Heidi Johnson, Rabjit Singh Johal, Edmund George, Jacqueline Nicole Babcock, Cheryl Lee Das, Ernie Nguyen and Mi Keun Lee

FINAL DECISIONS

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017fia002aetal.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 31, 2018

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-FIA-002

2017-FIA-003

2017-FIA-004

2017-FIA-005

2017-FIA-006

2017-FIA-007

2017-FIA-008

Decision Number:
2017-FIA-002(a)

2017-FIA-003(a)

2017-FIA-004(a)

2017-FIA-005(a)

2017-FIA-006(a)

2017-FIA-007(a)

2017-FIA-008(a)
Shahin Behroyan v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2018rsag01_prelim.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 15, 2018

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2018-RSA-002

2018-RSA-003

Decision Number:
—
Soheil Arman Kia (aka Soheil Armon Kia) v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

APPLICATION TO DELAY WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS

DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-MBA-002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 24, 2018

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2017-MBA-002

Decision Number:
2017-MBA-002(a)
Roger Bruce Schoen v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-002b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 19, 2018

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2017-RSA-002(b)
Jocelyn Fenelon v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-FIA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 17, 2018

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-FIA-001

Decision Number:
2017-FIA-001(a)
Roger Bruce Schoen v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

PRELIMINARY APPLICATION TO ADDUCE ADDITIONAL EVIDENCE

GRANTED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 20, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2017-RSA-002(a)
Financial Institutions Commission v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Seven Additional Respondents

APPLICATION FOR JOINDER APPEALS

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-FIA-002_etal_joinder.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 8, 2017

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-FIA-002

2017-FIA-003

2017-FIA-004

2017-FIA-005

2017-FIA-006

2017-FIA-007

2017-FIA-008

Decision Number:
—
Financial Institutions Commission v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Jacqueline Nicole Babcock

APPLICATION FOR STAY

DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-FIA-005_stay.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 7, 2017

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-FIA-005

Decision Number:
—
Financial Institutions Commission v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Seven Additional Respondents

APPLICATION FOR DISCLOSURE OF APPEAL RECORDS

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-FIA-002_etal_disclosure.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 13, 2017

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2017-FIA-002

2017-FIA-003

2017-FIA-004

2017-FIA-005

2017-FIA-006

2017-FIA-007

2017-FIA-008

Decision Number:
—
Cai Ming Yang v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia

COSTS DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-001b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 6, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2017-RSA-001(b)
Cai Ming Yang v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 25, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2017-RSA-001(a)
Yu-Hsiang (Lester) Lin v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016-RSA-002d.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 27, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-002(d)
Bella Daniels v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPEAL DECISION

DISMISSED WITH COSTS

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/FST_Decision_Daniels.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 19, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
FST 07-034

Decision Number:
—
Cui Zhu (Danielle) Deng v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL ALLOWED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016-RSA-001b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 13, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-001(b)
Cai Ming Yang v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia

PRELIMINARY DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-RSA-001_prelim.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 5, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2017-RSA-001

Decision Number:
—
Soheil Arman Kia (aka Soheil Armon Kia) v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-MBA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 13, 2017

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2017-MBA-001

Decision Number:
2017-MBA-001(a)
Murat Kadioglu v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

COSTS DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-003c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 7, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-003

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-003(c)
Cui Zhu (Danielle) Deng v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION TO AMEND NOTICE OF APPEAL

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016-RSA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
March 7, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-001(a)
Murat Kadioglu v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

STAY APPLICATION

DECLINED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-003_LT.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 22, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-003

Decision Number:
—
Yu-Hsiang (Lester) Lin v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION TO LIFT A STATUTORY STAY

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016rsa002c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 7, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-002(c)
Murat Kadioglu v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015rsa003b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 1, 2017

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-003

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-003(b)
Yu-Hsiang (Lester) Lin v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION TO ADDUCE NEW EVIDENCE

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016rsa002b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 9, 2016

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-002(b)
Yu-Hsiang (Lester) Lin v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

PRELIMINARY DECISION ON EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AND APPEAL AND TO ADDUCE NEW EVIDENCE

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016rsa002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 3, 2016

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2016-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2016-RSA-002(a)
Robert John Emil Hensel v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2016mba001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 19, 2016

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2016-MBA-001

Decision Number:
2016-MBA-001(a)
Pritpal Singh Mann v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-FIA-002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 12, 2016

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2015-FIA-002

Decision Number:
2015-FIA-002(a)
Gordon Stephen Lemon v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-MBA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 7, 2016

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2015-MBA-001

Decision Number:
2015-MBA-001(a)
Murat Kadioglu v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

PRELIMINARY APPLICATION

DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-003a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 18, 2016

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2018-RSA-003

Decision Number:
2018-RSA-003(a)
Pritpal Singh Mann v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

APPLICATION FOR STAY

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2017-FIA-005_stay-1.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 7, 2016

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2015-FIA-002

Decision Number:
—
James Sydney Parsons v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-002d.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
November 13, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-002(d)
Superintendent of Real Estate v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Richard Thomas Valouche

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-001c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 9, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-001(c)
Fransen Insurance Services Ltd. (dba Sea to Ski Insurance Services) and Antony Fransen v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

SUMMARY DISMISSAL

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-FIA-001_summary_dismissal.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 11, 2015

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2015-FIA-001

Decision Number:
—
James Sydney Parsons v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION TO AMEND THE NOTICE OF APPEAL

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-002c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 14, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-002(c)
Fransen Insurance Services Ltd. (dba Sea to Ski Insurance Services) and Antony Fransen v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

STAY APPLICATION

GRANTED WITH CONDITIONS

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-FIA-001_stay.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 8, 2015

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2015-FIA-001

Decision Number:
—
James Sydney Parsons v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION FOR A FURTHER EXTENSION OF TIME

GRANTED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-002b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
July 8, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-002(b)
Superintendent of Real Estate v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Richard Thomas Valouche

APPLICATION TO AMEND NOTICE OF APPEAL

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-001b.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
June 8, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-001(b)
James Sydney Parsons v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Superintendent of Real Estate

APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE SUBMISSIONS

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 29, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-002

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-002(a)
Superintendent of Real Estate v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia and Richard Thomas Valouche

REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO AMEND NOTICE OF APPEAL

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2015-RSA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
April 22, 2015

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2015-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2015-RSA-001(a)
Ashish Kulkarni v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2014-FIA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
May 29, 2014

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2014-FIA-001

Decision Number:
2014-FIA-001(a)
Mohamed Alie Jalloh v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

FINAL DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2012-FIA-002a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 7, 2012

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2012-FIA-002

Decision Number:
2012-FIA-002(a)
Chinweobi (Chiobi) Anoliefoh v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL ALLOWED IN PART

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2012-RSA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
October 22, 2012

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2012-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2012-RSA-001(a)
A Director and SSEI Insurance Agency Ltd. v. Insurance Council of British Columbia and Financial Institutions Commission

APPLICATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AN APPEAL

DENIED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2012-FIA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
August 31, 2012

Act:

Financial Institutions Act

File Number:
2012-FIA-001

Decision Number:
2012-FIA-001(a)
Keith Allan Cook v. The Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

PRELIMINARY ISSUE OF JURISDICTION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2011-MBA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
January 18, 2012

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
2011-MBA-001

Decision Number:
2011-MBA-001(a)
Brewers’ Distributor Ltd. v. Brewery, Winery and Distillery Workers, Local 300 and Superintendent of Pensions

COSTS DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2010-PBA-001c.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 21, 2011

Act:

Pension Benefits Standards Act

File Number:
2010-PBA-001

Decision Number:
2010-PBA-001(c)
Vikram Singh Atwal v. Real Estate Council of British Columbia

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2010-RSA-001a.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
February 17, 2011

Act:

Real Estate Services Act

File Number:
2010-RSA-001

Decision Number:
2010-RSA-001(a)
Brewers’ Distributor Ltd. v. Brewery, Winery and Distillery Workers, Local 300 and Superintendent of Pensions

FINAL DECISION

APPEAL DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2010pba001_decision.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
December 10, 2010

Act:

Pension Benefits Standards Act

File Number:
2010-PBA-001

Decision Number:
—
Brewers’ Distributor Ltd. v. Brewery, Winery and Distillery Workers, Local 300 and Superintendent of Pensions

INTERIM DECISION

APPLICATION DISMISSED

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/2010pba001_interim.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 30, 2010

Act:

Pension Benefits Standards Act

File Number:
2010-PBA-001

Decision Number:
—
Get Acceptance Corporation and Keith Bryan Westergaard and Frank Iantorno and Evergreen Mortgage Corporation v. Registrar of Mortgage Brokers

APPEAL DECISION

File:
https://www.bcfst.ca/app/uploads/sites/832/2020/07/FST08_040AppealDecision.pdf

Date Decision Issued:
September 5, 2009

Act:

Mortgage Brokers Act

File Number:
FST 08-040

Decision Number:
—

Preliminary and Final Decisions

Acts